Maine Supreme Judicial Court Takes Center Stage at Deering High School
On Wednesday, October 9, the Deering High School auditorium transformed into a courtroom as the Maine Supreme Judicial Court held oral arguments in front of over 100 eager students. This unique event offered a rare opportunity for high schoolers to witness the workings of Maine’s judicial system up close, fostering a deeper understanding of civics and the pursuit of justice.
The six justices, seated on stage in their judicial robes, heard three appeals cases, providing students with an authentic glimpse into the legal process. “It’s a lesson in civics that hopefully will stay with them for the rest of their lives,” said Rep. Samuel Zager, D-Portland, who played a key role in bringing the court to the school. He emphasized the importance of showing students the lengths to which society goes to ensure justice.
This initiative is part of a longstanding tradition that began in 2005, where the Maine Supreme Judicial Court visits high schools across the state each October. Since then, the court has made its way to at least 47 schools, hearing over 134 appeals. Deering High School was particularly special this year, as it marked the first time the court had visited Portland students since 2011.
Students from Deering, Casco Bay, and Portland High Schools gathered to observe the proceedings, which included cases that sparked lively discussions. The first case revolved around the applicability of a Good Samaritan law to a man found operating under the influence when police were called for a medical emergency. The second case involved a man seeking to overturn his conviction for hindering the arrest of his brother, who had been acquitted of murder. The final case examined traffic laws concerning how far to the right a bicyclist must ride to allow vehicles to pass safely.
After each case, students had the chance to engage directly with the lawyers involved, asking questions about the arguments and legal processes. Attorneys Maureen Sturtevant and James Spizuoco facilitated this interaction, making the experience even more enriching. Sturtevant, a parent at a nearby elementary school, and Spizuoco, a Deering High School alumnus, brought a personal touch to the proceedings.
The decorum of the court left a lasting impression on the students. “It was cool seeing them like that, and also them asking us to stand and sit like we’re actually at the court,” said Deering senior Keira King. “It felt real.” Social studies teachers had prepared students by reviewing the cases beforehand, encouraging them to think critically about the arguments presented.
Deering High School teacher Darcie Drew noted the value of this experience for her students. “I think it was really interesting for them to hear the justices and then ask some of the same questions they were considering while looking at the case,” she said.
In attendance alongside the students were notable figures including House Speaker Rachel Talbot Ross, state Rep. Edward Crockett, and Portland City Councilor Pious Ali. Rep. Zager expressed his hope that the event would inspire students amid the challenges they face in today’s world. “It’s so important to make sure that the younger generation has hope and sees the mechanics of a fair trial,” he said.
For students like sophomore Charlie Dibble, the experience was eye-opening. He reflected on the distinction between fact and truth, noting how the justices dissected arguments. “Just seeing that in action and seeing professionals tear that apart is so cool,” he said.
Another sophomore, Jaidan Mann, attended all three oral arguments and expressed his surprise at the justices’ rapid-fire questioning. Aspiring to become a lawyer, Mann dressed for the occasion in a burgundy suit, declaring, “It’s a once-in-a-lifetime scenario. It’s not every day that the Maine Supreme Court comes to your high school.”
As the event concluded, it was clear that the visit from the Maine Supreme Judicial Court had left a profound impact on the students of Deering High School, igniting their interest in the law and the principles of justice that underpin society.
