Nutley, N.J. – Tensions Flare in First Senate Debate Between Kim and Bashaw
In a lively and contentious first debate for New Jersey’s open Senate seat, Democratic Rep. Andy Kim and Republican Curtis Bashaw squared off on key issues like abortion and immigration, setting the stage for what promises to be a heated election season. The debate, held in Nutley, comes in the wake of former Senator Bob Menendez’s resignation following his conviction on bribery charges, leaving a significant vacancy in the state’s political landscape.
From the outset, the debate was marked by sharp exchanges. Kim, a three-term representative from New Jersey’s 3rd District, didn’t hold back in criticizing Bashaw’s ties to former President Donald Trump, questioning the sincerity of Bashaw’s self-proclaimed support for abortion rights. “I just fundamentally have a problem with using the term ‘pro-choice’ to describe yourself when you have talked about the importance of the Dobbs decision being correctly decided,” Kim asserted, referring to the Supreme Court ruling that overturned Roe v. Wade.
Bashaw, a hotel developer and first-time candidate, attempted to position himself as a moderate voice in the Republican Party. He emphasized his support for abortion rights, stating, “I am pro-choice, congressman. I am for freedom in the home.” He also highlighted his personal experiences, noting that he is a married gay man, and argued that government should not dictate personal choices regarding marriage or reproductive health.
The debate took an unexpected turn when Bashaw paused mid-sentence, appearing nonresponsive before being escorted off the stage for about ten minutes. Upon his return, he explained, “I got so worked up about this affordability issue that I realized I hadn’t eaten so much food today. So I appreciate your indulgence.” This moment of vulnerability added a human touch to the otherwise heated discussion.
Immigration emerged as another hot topic, with Bashaw labeling it “a crisis in New Jersey” and criticizing the financial burden it places on the state. He directed his closing remarks specifically to women and mothers, aiming to connect with voters who may feel the impact of these issues in their daily lives. “I am a moderate, common-sense person that will work to be a voice for New Jersey,” he declared.
Kim, who launched his campaign immediately after Menendez’s indictment, has been positioning himself as a fresh alternative to the state’s political establishment. His candidacy gained momentum after first lady Tammy Murphy withdrew from the race, allowing him a clearer path to the Democratic nomination. Kim’s legal challenge against New Jersey’s unique ballot-drawing system, which many believe favors party-backed candidates, has also drawn attention, with a federal judge siding with him and putting the system on hold for this election.
As the debate wrapped up, it was clear that both candidates are gearing up for a fierce battle in a state that has leaned Democratic for decades. Kim, who gained national recognition for his actions during the January 6 Capitol insurrection, and Bashaw, who recently won a contested primary against a Trump-backed opponent, are both eager to make their mark in this pivotal race.
With Menendez’s resignation still fresh in voters’ minds, the stakes are high for both candidates as they vie for a seat that has been held by Democrats for over five decades. As the election approaches, New Jerseyans can expect more spirited debates and discussions on the issues that matter most to them.
